Courtar challenges Government’s explanation after VOG ruling
ORANJESTAD, St. Eustatius – Lenaldo Courtar has responded to Government’s statement on the court ruling that upheld the Island Governor’s refusal to issue him a Certificate of Good Conduct (VOG) for the position of Search and Rescue Coordinator. While accepting the Court’s judgment, Courtar says important questions about the decision remain unanswered.
The Court of First Instance ruled on September 1 that Island Governor Alida Francis was justified in refusing the VOG, taking into account Courtar’s 2023 convictions for migrant smuggling and forgery and the responsibilities associated with the SAR coordinator position.
In a lengthy response, Courtar argues that Government has still not sufficiently explained what specific risks his convictions pose in relation to the actual duties of a SAR coordinator. He maintains that the position primarily involves coordinating rescue personnel and resources and does not provide immigration powers or authority over criminal investigations.
Courtar also points out that he continued to participate in rescue-related activities after his 2023 conviction. According to him, Government and other authorities were aware of his legal situation but continued to involve him in SAR activities and training. He questions why his record is now considered incompatible with the coordinator position if it did not previously prevent his involvement.
He is also seeking clarification on when a VOG became a requirement for SAR volunteers and whether the same requirement applies to all candidates.
Courtar further notes that Government itself acknowledged a procedural issue identified by the Court concerning how the VOG decision was formally communicated. The Governor’s Cabinet has said it will strengthen its procedures following the ruling.
Despite disagreeing with aspects of Government’s handling and explanation of the case, Courtar said he accepts the Court’s judgment and intends to continue contributing to St. Eustatius in other ways.
Courtar’s complete response can be read here.
